 |
Feature Articles
|
 |
|
|
Harassment or Rescue?
On the Trail with Mark Kayser
POSTED BY: Mark Kayser
April 29, 2010
Whale watchers in Puget Sound last week had an opportunity to watch National Geographic up close and personal. While watching a gray whale in the sound nearly 30 tourists on a whale watching charter saw a group of killer whales attack the whale. The killer whales hammered it from below and then dove with it as it tried to escape. When the whale resurfaced, belly up, the killer whales hit it again from below. Finally the gray whale limped toward shore and the attacking killer whales didn't follow.
When everyone thought the event was finished another pair of killer whales targeted the wounded whale, but the quick thinking captain of the charter positioned the boat to deter another attack.
That started me thinking. If a boat captain can step in and stop nature from occurring, then can't the rest of us do the same? Next time one of us happens upon a wolf attacking an elk, can't we just aim our truck at the attacking wolf and deter the attack? Or what if we see a mountain lion preying on a whitetail? Is it OK to fire a couple of warning shots over the bow of the cat to stop the attack? Who draws the line with Mother Nature?
Somehow I don't think those antics would be met with as much acceptance and we'd be labeled as harassers, not rescuers.
Comments
By
azduane
Thursday, April 29, 2010 4:20 PM
You're right. But remember whales have been deified to a point of no return. Wolves are close to being treated the same as whales and of course elephants never, ever, destroy their own habitat and overpopulate. I guess, in many instances, it comes off as to how "cute" the animal can be made to appear to the unknowing public.
By
AZsparrow
Friday, April 30, 2010 11:19 AM
I hear ya'... In reality, I think that whale was toast anyway. I'm sure the killer whales came back for the wounded, or weakened grey whale eventually.
By
speterson9
Friday, April 30, 2010 4:10 PM
I'm not against ecotourism but I have a real problem when nature is interfeared with by people who are supposedly trying to educate the public. As we all know whales eat other whales and fish and just because the killer whale is more abundant doesn't mean it's role in nature is less important. They saved one gray whale (possibly) and in doing so might have endagered the rest of the gray whale population. Since the predator preys on the week and infirm, that boat captain could helped to cause a major outbreak of some whale disease. And for what? Because someone on his boat would have been shocked by the fact that when Willie is free he has to feed himself? That boat captain should have been heavily reprimanded of fined.
By
HectorLozano
Saturday, May 01, 2010 12:07 AM
I guess it is depend who is the pray. If the pray is an animal in danger of extinction or it is an animal that is rare in the area, then yes, I would try to deter the attack of the predator. If the pray is an animal that could be found in good numbers in the area, then I won't interfere with the food chain and would let mother nature doing what she does better: find her own "equilibrium" between pray and predator.
By
DSHEMAK
Sunday, May 02, 2010 10:14 AM
I agree. What would have happened if the "boat" wasn't there should have been what happened. Period. That is how life in the wild works. One preys on another. Food chain ethics. Checks and balances. What ever you call it. It has been going on for a lot longer than "do gooders" have been interfering.
By
alderdog
Monday, May 03, 2010 10:32 AM
All I will say is, the captain of that boat was wrong, and in doing what he did probably broke the law. Federal regulations require all boater to stay at least 100 yards away from any marine mammals, and the last time I checked, killer whales are mammals!
By
bmartin11
Tuesday, May 18, 2010 3:37 PM
well this is a very touchy subject wild animals do not have grocery stores to buy their food they are either prey or predators and have to eat as well, it is our human nature to think that by stepping in to save one animals life is a good deed, but for example with the wolf attacking an elk, well this is nature and how mother nature intends things and by deturing that wolf from making a kill whos to say its not jeopardizing the health and life of her pups? these incidents may be hard to watch or witness but its a fact of life and the wild nature we as humans have intruded enough and need to learn to let nature and the things that happen in nature take their course
|
|
|
|