Hunting Blogs

The Dry-Fire Dilemma: Is It Safe To Dry Fire A Gun?

By: Ron Spomer

Aug 24

There's a simple, two-part answer to the age-old question: “Is it safe to dry fire my gun?” Yes. And no.
    
Sorry, folks. There is no one-size-fits-all answer. You can dry fire some guns thousands of times with no damage. With others, one dry fire could send a firing pin flying down the barrel.
    
The good news is that nearly all modern rifles, handguns and shotguns can be safely dry fired. The bad news is that even these can break or wear unduly. And how do you define “nearly all”?

Shooters just want a straight answer. “Can I dry fire my Winchester Model 70 without fear of anything breaking? How about my Smith & Wesson AR or Mossberg M500 shotgun?”

Your local gunsmith or I could tell you to dry fire away because we've never seen nor heard of such practice damaging the brand and model of rifle you specify, but there's always the first time. Heck, I wouldn't even tell you it's perfectly safe to live fire your gun because I don't know:

1. How well maintained the gun is.
2. If the barrel is plugged by a wasp nest.
3. If you're using the correct cartridges.
4. If you're using handloads with double doses of pistol powder.  

I can guarantee this about dry firing: It will make you a better shot. Champion target shooters dry fire regularly. It teaches trigger control, indoors and inexpensively. Keep a safe, unloaded rifle beside the TV easy chair and dry fire during commercials. No flinching. Just finding a target in the scope, dry firing and cycling builds muscle memory and makes rifle handling as automatic as forking pie into your mouth. Smart shooters want to dry fire.

You won't destroy a gun if you dry fire it, but you could damage or break the firing pin. The pin is designed to slam against a yielding metal primer; without it, the pin will bash against an unyielding metal rim or bushing within the action or bolt body. Rimfire firing pins strike the edge of the breech/chamber. This is supposed to break rimfire firing pins or severely gall the breech, yet an experiment conducted by Jeff Johnston of the NRA showed that 1,000 dry fires in a Henry pump-action .22 LR and a Browning Buck Mark II pistol resulted in no visible damage to either's firing pin, slight marring of the breech face in the Henry and no marring of the Browning from the firing pin. The Browning's extractor did wear its chamber slightly. No subsequent firing malfunctions (through 500 rounds) resulted from the dry firing.

But again, these were just two rifles. Who's to say a Marlin, Savage, Ruger, Kimber or any other firearm will match that?

Fortunately, there are two simple, cheap solutions to the dry-firing dilemma: Ask the manufacturer if it's safe to dry fire your gun, or use snap caps.
    
Some gun makers will tell you to dry fire at will, while others will hedge their bets and say to use snap caps. So just get the snap caps ($1-$22) and be done with it. Snap caps are fake cartridges that absorb firing-pin energy. They make dry firing more realistic by maintaining the feel and function of ammunition cycling through your firearm.

You can get snap caps right here from Brownell's, right here from Cabela's, or right here at Midway USA

31 comments

# jcoble1
Friday, August 24, 2012 10:17 AM
I use snap caps and paint the bullet section with orange paint to be sure i have no live ammo (always make sure there is no live ammunition in your dry fire area) safety first.
# npaul
Friday, August 24, 2012 11:06 AM
These snap caps look like a great product and I will need to get some. I had thought that maybe a spent cartridge might aid in preserving the firing pin but I don’t know that a dented primer would be very effective. The snap caps are a much better option.
# jstratton
Friday, August 24, 2012 11:16 AM
I shoot IDPA, USPSA and Three Gun Matches and we have to dry fire our handguns after we show an empty chamber and close the slide. This is to show the Range Officer that our handgun is clear. We use chamber flags in long guns to show an empty chamber.I have been doing this for over 5 years and I have never heard of dry firing causing any problems. I would rather be safe than not.
I will say you should NEVER dry fire a bow!!!
From a Hunter Safety Instructor.
# stevenbradford
Friday, August 24, 2012 3:52 PM
I don't like to dry fire any gun it's not safe and not good on firing pin
# jbw223
Friday, August 24, 2012 9:44 PM
I dry fire my rifles and handguns ALOT, I've never had a problem. Practice, practice, practice!
# atwitchell
Saturday, August 25, 2012 12:01 AM
Snap caps do well. Also dry firing does help with memory with trigger pull
# RAbear51
Saturday, August 25, 2012 7:07 AM
So..in the face of uncertainty and ambiguity of any answer the bottom line appears to be...use snap-caps.Why not? seems to be the best,fail-safe option. I didn't see any definite proof offered that dry firing "is not good on firing pin" and IF the gun is clearly empty I don't see a safety issue but again I didn't detect ANY definitive answer to the question posed but the suggestion of using snap-caps seems to put the whole question into the category of "moot". So I will install a snap-cap and FIRE AT WILL !!!
# Dlittle89
Sunday, August 26, 2012 3:42 PM
Snap caps also allow you to practice failures stick one in randomly in your magazine so while your firing you will encounter and dud and have to clear it
# chrisbyrd
Sunday, August 26, 2012 5:05 PM
When I was in the military, dry firing our M16A1/A2 was part of the function check after reassembling your rifle after cleaning. Also putting a dime on the top end of the barrel and dry firing to practice trigger squeeze.But those were M16's, and it didn't seem to hurt the firing pins in my experience with them. Snap caps sounds like a smart idea if a person was going to dry fire on a continuous basis on any of their weapons. Why risk it. Buy the caps.
# singerpeak85
Sunday, August 26, 2012 9:11 PM
or you could just use empty cartridges. same effect as a live round, only without the bang. just make sure all rounds you put in are fired and empty. then go at it. no risk, no cost. simple.
# dcarter11
Monday, August 27, 2012 12:46 PM
you know singerpeak85 that you somehow knew I was going to sat that and you stole my thunder. or could it be that great minds thing alike. but then again the Snap Caps could be a good idea for for people who want to spend the money on them and Its sounds to me like its not that exspencive. As for me and my house we are going to stick to the Brass.
# WSUMMERS
Monday, August 27, 2012 2:41 PM
DCarter11, I suggest the Snap Caps... you don't ever see 'live' (the spent ones look nearly the same) rounds in the cylinder or magazine. But, as Dlittle89 suggests: using a fired round in the magazine (or cylinder) does avoid knowing when to expect the jam/misfire. This should be done ONLY on the range, where live-fire is the norm.
# Motoboy
Monday, August 27, 2012 8:47 PM
As an ex armorer in the military we taught many a recruit the art of shooting and proper weapon sighting, trigger control and breathing through the dry firing process before they were allowed to shoot live ammo. We must have dry fired those m16's a milion times over the six years I was involved. Not one failure of a firing pin was I aware of. However: we did see primer rupture occasionally due to the firing pin piercing the primer when using live ammo. When measured we found the firing pin had set back the built in stop between the bolt and the pin. This caused the protruding part of the pin to strike deeper into the primer and rupture the primer occasionally. On a personal note: before snap caps were sold we would remove the spent primer from a fired case, (from that weapon) and install a leather plug we cut out of a strip of leather with a leather punch, glue it in place and we could dry fire away for many rounds before the leather was beat up enough it needed replacing. Never saw any signs of wear on the firing pin by doing this. Snap caps are the way to go if your afraid of damaging the firing pin. My two cents worth!!
# jakeraney87
Wednesday, August 29, 2012 7:21 PM
AR series, bolt action and pump weapon even some pistols can be dry fired. Now certain revolvers, and auto loading pistols can not be because the round itself acts as a stop for the for the hammer or striker. Certain matchine guns can not be dry fired because they operate on what is known as an open bolt system in which the round is on the bolt face and is driven into the barel face rotating the bolt to fire the round. Without the presents of brass or the primer to stop the striker or the bolt weapon over time will become damaged. So most of your every day weapons can be dry fired with no unusual damage wear and tear to the weapon. This does not mean dry fire your weapon all the time parts will wear out just as if you were to shoot it all the time springs is a prime example of this.
# odiesbsc
Friday, August 31, 2012 3:14 PM
Motoboy, I was thinking of basicly the same thing as using a spent case with the primer removed with a piece of hard rubber from a truck tire glued in. But i think the leather might be a better choice. I'll have to give it a try. Thanx for the tip.
# ptaylor57
Friday, August 31, 2012 10:38 PM
The only gun i had a firing pin break on was a squires bingham 22 cal rifle, but other than that i haven't any problems. But using an empty case is one of the better ways..
# alsf62
Saturday, September 01, 2012 9:14 AM
alsf62 I once dry fired my Remington 870 And the next week i was trying to shoot at a buck and nothing happened , i took the bolt out right there in the field and sure enough the pin was broken.
# wamshane
Saturday, September 01, 2012 6:53 PM
Snap caps are not that expensive and it sure does help to get the feel for the trigger pull...
# teamd&b biggamehunters
Monday, September 03, 2012 9:43 AM
I had a marlin 30-30 break a firingpin dry firing it becouse of that i us snapp caps
# TLM
Tuesday, September 04, 2012 9:42 AM
I use spent cases, remove the primer and fill the primer pocket with a hot glue gun. After the glue is dry i cut it flat with a razor blade. This will last for a long time.
# dsboiler
Tuesday, September 04, 2012 11:18 AM
Just FYI. Snap caps do not work in my American Tactical/GSG 1911 22. For some reason they jam and will not load into the chamber correctly. Too light I think.
# dzachow
Tuesday, September 04, 2012 7:16 PM
In 38 years of extreme firearm hunting and trap shooting I have yet to have a legitimate reason to dry fire.
# hsallee
Wednesday, September 05, 2012 7:47 AM
I was always taught NOT to dry fire, but when I taught my mother-in-law (who is terrified of guns) to shoot I had her do a little dry firing just to get the feel of the trigger without the bang. It helped her a lot.
# Stutgrtguy
Wednesday, September 05, 2012 5:50 PM
I was always under the impression that rim fires were a no-no to dry fire but all the rest were fine. I make a habit out of not dry firing any firearm but I do sometimes when cleaning and maintenance.
# Anonymous User
Thursday, September 06, 2012 10:55 AM
Top Tips To Improve Shooting Accuracy
# dwillyerd
Thursday, September 06, 2012 2:29 PM
Does anyone know about using spent cartridges with the primer removed?
# tinman83
Friday, September 07, 2012 11:16 AM
I've removed the primers and used pencil erasers in the primer pockets also
# jharvatin
Friday, September 07, 2012 1:41 PM
I have always dry fired my weapons and never had an issue with any of them .
# dzachow
Saturday, September 08, 2012 7:38 PM
Sorry "Anonymous User", I don't care what your article says, I'll never be convinced to dry fire and I shoot just fine. On the very rare occasion of a miss fire I cringe, even if it's not from my gun.
# norman1
Sunday, September 09, 2012 10:31 AM
I have a S&W Sigma 9mm and i have to dry fire it to remove the slide , never had a issue with it.
# jrmigs
Monday, September 10, 2012 10:38 AM
For finger exercise, I have an old (cheap) bb CO2 pistol that has a remarkably similar pull to my .357. You might also experiment with airsoft guns - the actual fire point will probably not match your gun, but it will strengthen your finger. Try aiming at a point and squeezing without significant deviation. Since I have a .357 I also try keeping my hand very tight (for muzzle control) while developing a soft smooth finger pull.

Post Comment

Only registered users may post comments.