Hunting Blogs

Would You Shoot a White Deer?

By: J.R. Absher

Apr 26

Thanks to legislation signed last week by Oklahoma Gov. Mary Fallin, hunters in The Sooner State no longer need special permission to shoot white or piebald deer during the regular hunting seasons.

Since 1998, Oklahoma hunters were required by law to obtainwritten permission from the state wildlife director before harvesting an albino, white or piebald (brown with white patches) white-tailed deer.

Like with many decidedly obscure hunting regulations across the country, Oklahoma’s “white deer rule” was not widely known and understood among sportsmen, which led to an embarrassing situation for a former state lawmaker a couple of years ago—and eventually to the passage of House Bill 1314 this year.

During the 2010 Oklahoma rifle deer season, state Representative Terry Harrison was so excited about the piebald deer he shot that he submitted a photo of himself posed with the unique specimen to the "McAlester News-Capital," where it appeared on the front page of the sports section. Shortly thereafter, the newspaper—and Rep. Harrison—began receiving calls questioning whether he had obtained the proper permit to kill a piebald deer. He had not.

As a result, Harrison was fined $296, issued a public apology and said he hoped other hunters “can learn from my mistake.”

With this month’s official repeal of the prohibition and special permit, white and piebald deer are now fair game for Oklahoma hunters. In 2008, responding to similar confusion among hunters and game wardens, the Michigan Natural Resources Commission voted to drop that state’s longtime regulation that prohibited hunting albino or all-white deer.

However, some states continue to prohibit hunters from taking pure albino deer, but allow the harvest of piebald animals. At last check, Illinois, Iowa, Minnesota, Tennessee and Wisconsin do not allow hunters to take albinos.

And in Iowa, deer that are more than 50-percent white are strictly protected. Just imagine doing the math while in a treestand, bearing down on a big buck!

Would you shoot a white deer? Comment below.

16 comments

# FRUlery
Thursday, April 26, 2012 8:33 AM
I have only seen one white deer on the hoof and I let it pass. No law preventing me from harvesting the animal, just my choice. besides being white, it was a young buck and I was looking for something bigger for the freezer. My primary hunting state is Kentucky.
# npaul
Thursday, April 26, 2012 10:27 AM
I have never seen one but if I had the opportunity I would. It would have to be a mature buck but other than that, what an awesome trophy.
I will have to check the laws for Washington State.
# khorn109
Thursday, April 26, 2012 12:25 PM
I it depends on you view.One you could leave it to breed and thus have more albino deer,or you could kill it to show off to everyone.For myself I would not shoot it.
# mmclaughlin3
Thursday, April 26, 2012 1:27 PM
I would shoot it, but only if it was a mature adult deer.
# Riisuuntukaa
Thursday, April 26, 2012 2:04 PM
If its legal for me to shoot, then absolutely. Im hunting more for the amazing meat provided than for a trophy, but I would definitely look into getting that hide tanned..
# erniejantz
Thursday, April 26, 2012 2:51 PM
I would shoot it. I have read that they are geneticly inferior and that most of them don't live very long.
# jflynn511
Thursday, April 26, 2012 4:49 PM
I think the albino deers should be protected defenetly until their population grows in big numbers. And then have a size and age restriction on harvesting only certain ones. I also think they should lighten up on harvesting the piebald deer.
# lallen7
Thursday, April 26, 2012 4:56 PM
In past archery seasons (two different years) I pasted on opportunties to shoot at albino does. I'm quite superstitous and believe it to be bad luck to harvest an albino (just me).
# dzachow
Thursday, April 26, 2012 9:23 PM
I've already shot a white turkey and trapped a white possum, which both made beautiful mounts. A deer? Absolutely! I'd have that mounted too.
# drodgers4
Thursday, April 26, 2012 10:05 PM
I have never seen one but I would defenetly shoot one if I had the chanse .
# bsnyder8
Thursday, April 26, 2012 11:06 PM
I would love to shot a white or piebald deer.
# RAbear51
Friday, April 27, 2012 6:19 AM
Research has shown that albinism is a genetic FLUKE and isn't necessarily passed from offspring to offspring so we wouldn't end up with a huge population of them..if so why don't we have that yet?? I would shoot a PURPLE deer if I had the opportunity to and protecting genetically inferior animals just so you can "feel" good about it is emotional drip at the very least. I can remember when Michigan passed that absurd legislation because I was raised there and believe me the justification given was COMPLETELY emotion based and DID NOT originate with hunters. Several "white" and piebald deer were harvested over about a two year period and the public outcry caused by the Detroit News and Free Press articles and accompanying photos created a hysterical uproar among the Mich. "Humane" society and other rabble-rousing nit-wits who by virtue of their squealing and whining succeeded in bullying the legislature to pass the assinine restrictions that only served to create yet another way to make hunters outlaws.It "protected" nothing worthy of protection and was a laughing-stock bit of garbage among sensible,logical-thinking people..thus it's eventual demise. Same with Oklahoma..
# TCOMPARET
Friday, April 27, 2012 6:59 AM
First question, does it taste any different than a brown deer. Because I judge hunting success by filling a tag. You take the opportunites given. And hopefully you keep the grill occupied for a long time.
# mjbarkley
Friday, April 27, 2012 3:22 PM
i could not
# dzachow
Friday, April 27, 2012 8:00 PM
Very true RAbear51. You can not breed albinism. I read not to long ago that here in Wisconsin albino deer are illegal to shoot because they are P R E T T Y . Has anyone ever seen an albino person? I have.
# DSTATON
Tuesday, May 22, 2012 8:05 AM
they really aren't anything special! There total lack of Melatonin is the result! Are they pretty? yup they are. Will they reproduce an off spring like them? No! I have a picture of a Mom deer with two Fawns. One is normal and the other is black. that's from too much melatonin. There just freaks of nature. Now the Native Americans believe that the White Buffalo is sacred! that's ok ! I have a little of that blood flowing through my veins. In that sense I understand not shooting a White Buffalo. Would i shoot a White deer? in a heart beat. Some of the stupidest Laws are based on thoughts and not sound management or Science! It should remain a choice to shoot or not to shoot one based on your beliefs not others. as for management and Science based that's what we should be going by not poplar opinion!

Post Comment

Only registered users may post comments.