Hunting Blogs

Herd Management: You Can't Eat Antlers

By: Ainsley Beeman

Dec 06

Herd management: Though oftentimes a thankless job, somebody has to do it. No, I am not referring to the LSU Tigers removing the Arkansas Razorbacks from the list of contenders as they thin the ranks of the Southeastern Conference, but to the equally difficult and enjoyable task of harvesting antlerless deer.

My "Black Friday" was, like many of you, more of a Camo Friday. After sleeping in and catching up with Mom over coffee, followed by Thanksgiving leftovers that were off the charts at Granny’s, I visited a piece of whitetail utopia on the Mighty Mississippi River while bowhunting with my dad.

While heading to the stand we bumped several deer, including a couple nice-racked bucks. After getting settled in, things were quiet ... except for the hum of a tug boat pushing a barge up the river and a few Canada geese on a nearby sandbar. I must admit, something could have slipped past as my eyes were constantly scanning my iPhone for updates on the LSU/Arkansas battle for "The Boot." 

Eventually, a rustle in the sycamore leaves brought me to my feet as I prepared for a shot at a mature doe and yearling that were easing my way. While gauging the size of the smaller deer and pondering its ability to survive on its own, another doe appeared out of nowhere at half the distance. Her sagging profile and pot belly indicated she was past her prime. Obliged to take part in thinning the herd, I carefully drew two different times, only to have her stop each time behind limbs in the canopy. As she hastened her march to parts unknown, a loud bleat stopped her in her tracks, presenting a clear 23-yard shot quartering slightly away. It was "Goodnight, Irene." The little G5 Tekan expandable broadhead put her down within 60 yards.

Upon recovery, we discovered a dry doe with molars worn down to the gum line—a dinosaur if there ever was one. Additional text messages revealed that there would also be one less hog at the trough. It was a good day, indeed! As I’ve often said before, ”There ain’t nothing safe when there’s a Tiger around."

Let me encourage you to fill an antlerless tag next time you have the opportunity. Antlers are great, but you can’t eat them. And harvesting a doe from your deer herd means one less mouth for your habitat to support this winter.

As always, God bless and good hunting,
Ains
1 Theselonians 5:16-18
 

11 comments

# BBooth11
Tuesday, December 06, 2011 9:56 PM
Well done!
# btransburg
Wednesday, December 07, 2011 12:43 PM
I agree about the doe. I also like your reference at the end of the blog. Truth is always in season.
# dreamhunter65
Wednesday, December 07, 2011 1:50 PM
We did some doe thinning this gun season as all of the bucks both monsters and young ones disappeared into pine plantation adjoining our property that is a no hunt/no trespass area as a big anti-hunter owns it all...Tasty doe always good on the table and like my Dad always said also Antlers may look good on the wall but they do not make a good meal. 2 of my son's actually tag teamed a doe this year and for the younger one was his first deer..That always more special no matter buck or doe when they get the first one under their belt and seeing the smiles and knowing they will always hunt from now on. My kids have always been told we are meat hunters not horn hunters. If they get the buck great, if a nice doe gives them a opportunity take her as God is presenting them a gift.
# satkins39
Wednesday, December 07, 2011 2:00 PM
Thank you ma'am for the writing. I am a "meat hunter" first and then maybe antlers later. I know many people don't like to or will not take does at any time.....it's all about antlers. I often make the comment about not being able to eat antlers no matter how good they look. Doe harvest can also be critical to herd management, as you well know. I also greatly appreciate your reference to God and the scripture. I wish you a very wonderful Christmas.
# RAbear51
Thursday, December 08, 2011 5:52 AM
Ainsley,
Thanks for the article reminding all of the necessity of doe harvest. I grew up hunting whitetail in the northern woods of Michigan. In the spring after snow melt while turkey hunting you could see the resulting waste laying in the woods and fields everywhere you went. All deer that could have been harvested.Even with liberal antlerless harvest quotas in that state the winter die-off was shocking. I have lived in the western mountains of North Carolina for the past 9 years and hunt my own 50 acre plot and down here the local boys are still locked into the mis-informed belief that you don't shoot "momma" deer under Any circumstances. I don't adhere to that and usually take at least one doe per season and I have some bruiser bucks around to round out the season. Doe harvest is plain and simple a very sound and sensible management tool that has proven wrong all the misconceptions about wiping out the herd. It is as necessary to herd health as cover and food. Thanks for the accurate info. God Bless one and all and GOOD HUNTING !!
# AmericanUSA
Friday, December 09, 2011 9:07 PM
where i hunt its pretty much 65 acres of open field with two little draws on it so i'm not picky. I love to bow hunt and If a doe comes by and presents a clean shot i take it and thank god for the opportunity
# MSMITH
Saturday, December 10, 2011 2:21 PM
It's a shame that with all the information out there on thinning the herds actually helps the deer populations that people still refuse to kill does. I am a meat hunter first. What ever presents itself is going into the freezer. Missouri has a very open limit on does and recognizes the fact that the herd needs thinning. This year for gun season, 110,000 were taken. 60% were does. MO also has a long archery season, Sept 15th to Jan 15th. Throw in a black powder and youth hunt and you can see MO practices good herd management. The states estimated numbers is about 1.3 million deer and is very healthy.
# hittdoc7
Sunday, December 11, 2011 3:18 AM
WHAT YOU SAY IS THE ABSOLUTE TRUTH . THIS YEAR IN THE NC MOUNTAINS THERE WERE FEW ACORNS . WE ARE SEEING MORE DEER PICKING IN THE FIELDS ALL HOURS OF THE DAY. I HAVE COME TO REALIZE YOU CANT FEED THEM ALL. CORN HAS GOTTEN OUTRAGEOUSLY EXPENSIVE . LAST WINTER WE HAD SNOW COVER FROM MID -DECEMBER UNTIL FEBRUARY , SO I'M SURE MANY DEER STRUGGLED . WE HAVE HAD AN UNUSUALLY WARM DECEMBER SO FAR , BUT ONCE THE SNOW LAYS AND STAYS , THE COMPETITION FOR FOOD WILL BEGIN. SO YEAH , IT IS THE RIGHT THING AND WE WILL SEE IF THE "TIGERS CAN RIDE THE TIDE."
# bhuffstutler
Sunday, December 18, 2011 2:42 PM
you are on point i got six does to thin the herd and they sure do taste good would like to get big boy but cant pass on an old doe
# mmiller49
Saturday, January 07, 2012 2:26 PM
My 14 year old grand daughter shot her first ever deer this year. A doe, a big tender doe. She could have cared less weather that deer had antlers or not. As a matter of fact i had a big buck on trail cam her dad asked if she wanted to wait around to see if the buck came in, she said no this one will due. And as for meat in the freezer deer is the only meat that they eat, no beef, maybe a little pork now and then but mostly deer.
# MDIGGS
Friday, July 27, 2012 11:06 AM
I've never hunted for antlers when was legal to shoot a doe. I agree you can't antlers. As for the arkansas/lsu game, yes you did beat us but lsu and bama was the ONLY two teams to beat us

Post Comment

Only registered users may post comments.