Hunting Blogs

Deer Smuggling: Big Bucks, Big Fines

By: J.R. Absher

Oct 19

When you think about the clandestine operations involved in the smuggling business in Texas, you probably immediately think of the region straddling the U.S./Mexico border along the Rio Grande River, right?

Well, a new kind of smuggling taking place in Texas has nothing to do with illegal immigration or the illicit drug trade. This contraband is coming from northern states, where white-tailed deer have strong genetics and grow unusually large headgear. And it’s all about big bucks—as in greenbacks.

Last month, a prominent deer breeder from eastern Texas received the most costly fine and restitution order ever handed down in a wildlife-related crime after pleading guilty in June to illegally transporting at least 40 whitetails into Texas over a 3-year period from game farms in Illinois, Indiana, Pennsylvania and Ohio, in violation of state and federal statutes. Billy Powell, 77, was sentenced to 6 months of home confinement and a $1.5 million fine, sending a strong message to the Texas deer-breeding industry.

In his court testimony, Powell acknowledged that the fair market value of all of the illegally imported deer exceeded $800,000, that the value of the illegal deer semen exceeded approximately $961,000, and that the value of the offspring exceeded approximately $290,000.

An article in "The Houston Chronicle" this week  notes that a Texas A&M University study found deer breeding pumped $650 million into the U.S. economy 4 years ago, and was the fastest-growing industry in rural America. In Texas, permits have been issued to 1,233 breeders, who have 103,000 deer registered. Deer breeding is probably as common in The Lone Star State as anywhere in the country, and remains legal as long as it involves registered, captive deer from within the state.

“There’s a strong market for deer with those monster antlers. Hunters will pay thousands of dollars to bag one,” Michael Merida, special agent with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service in Fort Worth, told the Chronicle. “That’s why a frozen semen straw from a big-name buck can be worth $2,000, and a breeder can extract 70 or 80 straws at a time.”

In 2008, two men received jail time for Lacey Act violations in the smuggling of 14 trophy whitetail over a 4-year period from Minnesota to a Texas game ranch, where they planned to sell high-dollar hunts. Robert Eichenour, owner of Circle E Ranch in Grimes County, Texas, was sentenced to 18 months in federal prison, 36 months probation and fined $50,000. Brian Becker of Minnesota received 33 months in federal prison and 36 months probation.

“Texas game wardens and Fish and Wildlife agents continue to work together to deter illegal trafficking in wildlife across our state and across America,” said Col. Peter Flores, Texas Parks and Wildlife Department law enforcement division director. “The illegal trade may be perceived to be profitable for some, but the price to pay is high when they are caught, and we hope that this type of penalty will deter those who would engage in the illegal wildlife trade.”

4 comments

# dschultz8
Friday, October 21, 2011 9:58 AM
I personally wonder what the problem is. if these breeders are using them on their farms and not letting them loose in the general population then what is the harm. There is no difference then a farmer taking cattle or horses across state lines. These type of domesticated animals where once wild to. I see texas longhorns in Missouri and Kansas All the time should that be illegal. How did we get exotic animals into the U.S. maybe we should take these owners to prison too.
# dschultz8
Friday, October 21, 2011 10:02 AM
Also I know of instances when the Missouri Department of Conservation has bought deer from deer farms to help the gene pool here in Missouri.
# AaronBlaine
Friday, October 21, 2011 2:45 PM
yea thats crazy stuff i guess for the most part its to stop a massive profit from being made and i can understand how stocking a farm with BIG BUCKS will bring BIG BUCKS from rich hunters who could care less about bagging em the fair way. Finding a big beautiful Buck in the wild and bagging it knowing it was just you and mother nature instead of farmer bill and his semen sticks. I say keep hunting original and long live this American tradition. Dont let corporate America destroy hunting as well! Before you know it well be buying our bucks from china!
# jcribben
Friday, October 21, 2011 2:58 PM
That is crap just another way to gain revenue off of a smart busnis man I have a game ranch in California and it is miserable the crap we have to go through just to do busnis we are not hunting any thing other than farm bred animals goats sheep pigs ect but it is still a pain when we transport from auction or farms there are so many can not laws

Post Comment

Only registered users may post comments.